Why we left our “perfect” church
I think there’s a lot of tension around the idea of a “perfect” church. Obviously, we’re humans and only Christ is perfect (so we shouldn’t expect our churches to be perfect), but I think that there’s different kind of “perfect” that pertains to the church, and that’s what we’re going to talk about today. I firmly believe that there is a “perfect” church for each individual person, and this perfect church will look different for everyone. Everyone looks for different things in a church, so the “perfect” church would have the things that you want while also being life giving to you.
About a year ago Kaleb and I left our “perfect” church. It was really heartbreaking for us, and we haven’t really talked about it much. So, I think today I’m finally read to do that. Leading up to our marriage, Kaleb was attending Thomson First United Methodist, and once I got back from school I started attending the church too! We loved it.
The pastor of the church was John Barnes, and to this day he’s the best pastor I’ve ever had the privilege of listening to. You see, John was a very, very humble man and this quality showed in his preaching. With every sermon that John preached, you could see the preparation he put into the sermon. John set aside a few hours every day to work on his sermon. He prayed about his sermon and he made sure that the message he preached was really what God wanted for his congregation. His sermons were life giving. They had stories, but he never strayed from his scripture. John also used bullet points and always made sure to start with the bullet and come back to it at the end of that section to tie everything together. He made his sermons so easy to follow, but he also added points into his sermon for people that are further in their walks than others. I loved the stories and the bullet points, but Kaleb loved the historical context that he would add to his sermons. Every time John would preach he preached from a different place than most preachers. He had this understanding that he wasn’t good enough to be up there, but he was so humbled that God equipped him to be up there.
The people at Thomson First were the sweetest. Everyone was so welcoming to us. They always made a point to check in on Kaleb and I and to see how we were doing. It was a church where everyone loved everyone. This also followed into what the church did. The church was always taking up collections to bless and minister to different people. Thomson First was always trying to find good ways to help those in their community. I also loved this church because they realized that you don’t always have to go on a mission trip overseas to make a difference. Thomson first did a lot of missions in our city, state, and country. These are areas that a lot of churches tend to overlook because it sounds better to say I’ve sent x amount of mission teams to Africa. There was always something going on at Thomson First to help others.
I also really loved that Thomson First had three different services. The early service was small and just hymnal singing, the second service was a contemporary service, and the third service was a traditional service with a choir. The music in each service was executed so beautifully. I’ve never been to the early service, but I know it was more of a low-key service. Kaleb played electric guitar for the contemporary service. They practiced once during the week and then again right before the service. The band always asked questions to make sure that they were playing their part to the best of their ability, and they always loved being up on stage to worship God. Thomson’s tradition service was led by Brian Woods-Lusting, and he did an amazing job with that choir. He picked beautiful music that went with the service and he challenged his choir to do more complicated music than they were used to. To this day I can honestly say that the choir at Thomson First was one of the best I’ve heard. It was just such a nice church to go to when you’re a trained musician because you knew that these people put in as much time as you would have.
I could go on and on about TFUMC, but I’ll leave it there. I know at this point you’re probably wondering why we left, and the truth is that we left because things change, and they don’t always change for the better. You see, because this was a Methodist church, John had to leave. His time was up and it was time for him to go to his next church. When the new pastor came, Kaleb and I realized that his preaching style didn’t really speak to us like John’s style did. Before we left, Kaleb and I just started going to the young adults ministry and we loved that community, but it was time to go. In our opinion fellowship, ministry, and music are great, but those life changing messages from the pastor are what we crave the most. Around this time, Kaleb heard that he got a job working in Thomson, so we decided to head back to Augusta to find a church, so that Kaleb wasn’t having to drive to Thomson six out of seven days of the week.
After we left, Kaleb and I jumped around to different churches, but we never stayed at one for more than threeish months. It has been hard because everywhere we go, we compare the churches to TFUMC. People think we’re ridiculous for doing this, but we’ve seen that there are churches that are “perfect” for us. I was even able to find a “perfect” church in Milledgeville. The first couple of months at a new church are always great, but we always tend to find things that don’t sit well with us after a few months. We’re at a church now that we like, but we’ll have to see if it holds up to the test of time. -Tabatha